Litigation Consulting - QuickRead Top Story

The Construction Project Went Over Budget: What Went Wrong? (Part I of II)

Construction projects do not usually go as planned and sometimes, when delays and overruns occur, questions arise regarding fault and damages. A project can leave an unmistakable financial trail and still present a difficult causation question. Part I of this II Part series explains how construction professionals reconstruct what occurred, and why their findings set the boundaries of the economic damages analysis that follows.


A project can leave an unmistakable financial trail and still present a difficult causation question. This article explains how construction professionals reconstruct what occurred, and why their findings set the boundaries of the economic damages analysis that follows.

The project was expected to cost $10 million and take 18 months. It ultimately cost $13 million and required 24 months. Payroll records show sustained overtime. Equipment stayed on site longer than planned. The superintendent and project management team remained through the additional six months. Several subcontractors describe interrupted access and work performed out of sequence.

The parties agree on little beyond the final numbers. The owner attributes the result to weak planning, inadequate staffing, and inefficient performance. The contractor points to design revisions, delayed approvals, restricted access, changed work, and pressure to hold the original completion date.

What the Financial Records Establish

A cost report is built to accumulate dollars. A payroll register records hours, rates, and employees. An equipment invoice identifies the item rented, the charge, and the rental period. These records are important to measuring damages, but they generally are not created to explain the project sequence or why the work departed from the plan.

The difficulty begins as soon as more than one cause is plausible, which is common on a complex project. The overtime on the payroll could reflect changed scope, rework, poor estimating, reduced productivity, or an effort to recover lost time. The extended equipment and supervision could follow an owner-related delay, a contractor-caused delay, or several overlapping events. One financial symptom, several possible project conditions, and the records themselves do not say which.

A $13 million total records what was spent, subject to reconciliation and review. By itself, it does not establish why the project cost increased. Reading the $3 million overage as proof that one party caused it skips the analysis on which a damages opinion depends. The variance establishes the financial result. Determining causation requires a separate analysis of what happened, when it happened, which activities were affected, and how the project responded.

Delay, Disruption, and Acceleration

Take the delayed approval the contractor points to. It may look like a single event, but its effects can take several forms, and separating those effects is an important part of the analysis. If the approval pushes an activity later, the issue could be delay. Whether that delay affects project completion depends on whether the affected activity was on the then-current critical path; an activity can start or finish late and still not move the completion date when it carries float. If the trade continues working under fragmented access or out of sequence, the issue could be disruption, resulting in reduced productivity or efficiency. That effect should be supported by the project evidence rather than assumed.

If the contractor adds shifts or overtime to hold a milestone, the issue could be acceleration, though overtime by itself does not establish it, since the same hours can reflect recovery, added scope, or ordinary inefficiency. A single approval can produce all three at once, and the accounting records may capture them together as added labor, equipment, and supervision without separating one effect from another. The conditions overlap in time, yet they raise different construction questions and can carry different financial consequences.

Reconstructing the Project Chronology

Appropriately qualified construction professionals evaluate the technical cause and the project effect. Their work ordinarily begins with the contemporaneous record: the contract documents, baseline and updated schedules, daily reports, meeting minutes, requests for information, submittals, design revisions, change orders, field directives, progress photographs, labor and equipment records, and project correspondence.

No single document is likely to settle the dispute. The schedule may show when an activity moved. Daily reports may show who was on site and what work was done. Meeting minutes may capture an access restriction or a pending decision. An RFI may flag a design issue, while later correspondence shows when the response reached the work. The construction expert reads the records together to build a supported chronology.

That work may address which activities or trades were affected, whether sequencing changed, whether completion was extended, whether work proceeded under disrupted conditions, and whether added effort went into recovering time. It may also reveal several events crowding the same period, or gaps in the records that prevent a more precise assignment of effect.

The construction expert does not decide ultimate legal fault. Counsel evaluates contractual entitlement and the governing legal standards. A judge, jury, arbitrator, or other authorized decision-maker resolves disputed responsibility, and a mediator may help the parties evaluate and resolve the dispute. The expert’s role, however, is to weigh the technical evidence and explain what the project record supports. Whether a given effect is ultimately compensable turns on the contract, the governing law, notice and entitlement, and the findings the decision-maker accepts.

Applying the Construction Findings

An economic damages expert typically would not offer construction scheduling, engineering, or productivity opinions unless separately qualified and engaged to do so. The economic damages expert’s role as a financial analyst is to understand the construction findings well enough to apply them correctly and evaluate their financial implications.

This requires the analyst to evaluate the construction findings actively. The analyst should understand which event is being evaluated, which activities or trades were affected, when the impact began and ended, and whether the identified condition involved delay, disruption, acceleration, changed scope, or another effect. The analyst should also identify which technical assumptions remain disputed and how a different finding would change the calculation.

This review often surfaces practical problems before the model is finished. The construction opinion may fix a 90-day affected period while the invoices run six months past it. A disruption opinion may address one trade while the claim sweeps in labor from several unrelated ones. The schedule analysis may point to a later start date than the one used in the cost compilation. These inconsistencies directly affect which costs and periods the financial analysis can support and should be investigated and, where possible, resolved or disclosed before the report is drafted.

The findings also tell the analyst where to look, and where to stop. If the finding is a 90-day extension, the financial review may focus on costs that vary with duration during that period. If it is disruption to a particular trade, the review may focus on the labor and equipment tied to the affected activities. If it is acceleration, the analyst may examine added shifts, overtime premiums, supervision, equipment, and other incremental effort linked to the recovery plan.

The same structure supports rebuttal. A model can be rerun under a shorter period, a different affected trade, or the exclusion of a disputed event. A damages opinion is more useful when it shows how the financial conclusion moves with the technical findings than when it presents a single number that assumes every construction question has already been answered.

Defining the Financial Scope

Construction professionals reconstruct the events, the sequence, the affected work, and the project effects. The analyst’s task is to understand those findings, test them against the accounting evidence, and use them to define the financial scope.

Part II begins with those findings and follows the financial analysis from the but-for condition through incremental cost testing and reconciliation to net damages.


Daniel Basch, CPA, ABV, CFF, CVA, is Vice President, Economic Consulting, at Aperture. He advises attorneys, insurers, businesses, owners, and contractors on economic damages, forensic accounting, business valuation, and related financial issues in disputes and transactions. His work includes lost profits, business interruption, claimed damages, expert rebuttal, and construction-related financial analysis. Mr. Basch serves as an expert witness and prepares expert reports and financial analyses for use in disputes. He also serves in professional leadership roles with the AICPA and FICPA focused on credentialing, examination development, and professional education.

Mr. Basch may be contacted at (941) 773-7806 or by e-mail to dan.basch@aperturellc.com.

The National Association of Certified Valuators and Analysts (NACVA) supports the users of business and intangible asset valuation services and financial forensic services, including damages determinations of all kinds and fraud detection and prevention, by training and certifying financial professionals in these disciplines.