Are You Prepared for the Outcome? What can parties in a litigation case do when the experts come to differing opinions of value? The authors share ways that parties and counsel can reconcile the differences or at least reduce the value gap. It sounds great—if the valuation experts can resolve their differences, a trial might be avoided, saving time and money. This strategy is not without peril, and clients may even find themselves unexpectedly bound by an agreement or terms they did not expect. This article covers what ensues when opposing legal counsels agree for the experts to meet, including…
-
-
You are not Limiting Yourself There is a lot of disruption going on in the BVFLS industry and you should give niching a fair shot if you have more of a generalist-type practice. In this article, Rod Bukert shares his views on how to overcome the fears of specialization. There is a lot of disruption going on in our industry; from accounting/business valuation firm mergers to big data valuation solutions to finding qualified staff. Now is the time to either leave or dig your heels in. One way of doing the latter is by specializing in a niche and being…
-
Speaking from Experience Mediation aims for parties to mutually resolve their dispute. Unlike litigation and arbitration, there is no trier of fact that determines the conclusion of a dispute. Instead, the mediator, a neutral third party, tries to help all parties meet at an amicable middle ground, which can be done through creative means of communication, collaboration and problem solving. The author shares his experience serving as a financial mediator. Mediation aims for parties to mutually resolve their dispute. Unlike litigation and arbitration, there is no trier of fact that determines the conclusion of a dispute. Instead, the mediator, a…
-
Recognize Ethical and Professional Standards of Using AI AI is pervasive and promises to fundamentally transform business operations, education, and daily life. However, functional insights bridging the gap between AI and our industry have been lacking. The authors share their views on the ethical and professional standards implicated from the use of AI in forensics and valuation engagements. This article explores the need for, or lack thereof, to disclose the use of artificial intelligence (AI) technology in the fields of business valuation and financial forensics. AI is pervasive and promises to fundamentally transform business operations, education, and daily life. However,…
-
The Failed “Doc Fix” The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) released its finalized Medicare Physician Fee Schedule (MPFS) for calendar year (CY) 2025. The finalized fee schedule cut payments to physicians, and Congress declined to step in and mitigate the cuts in its last-minute legislation to fund the federal government for another three months. This article discusses the provisions contained in the MPFS final rule and the failed “doc fix” legislation. On November 1, 2024, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) released its finalized Medicare Physician Fee Schedule (MPFS) for calendar year (CY) 2025, aiming “to…
-
When to Use in Litigation Assignments In a recent engagement, the author was asked to prepare a lost business analysis for an operating business. In this article, the author discusses when a lost profits vis-à-vis a lost business analysis is best suited. Recently, I received a call from a new client. That is, I spoke with an attorney with whom I had worked in the past. He wanted to hire me to assess damages in a commercial damages case. The business had been injured by an alleged wrongful act. It was still operating and did not appear to be closing…
-
The Court Assess Substantive and Procedural Advanced to Disqualify Expert Witness This article provides an in-depth review of a recent infringement, unfair competition and cybersquatting where Plaintiff sought disgorgement of profits. The case highlights procedural and substantive arguments advanced during litigation and basis the Court used to partly disqualify the testimony of defendant’s expert witness. It also serves as a caution and learning opportunity for current and prospective financial damages expert witnesses. Plaintiff, Mission1st Group, Inc. (“M1G”), owns the federally registered trademark MISSION1st in connection with business advisory, information, technology, telecommunications, engineering support, and risk mitigation services. Plaintiff provides these…
-
Mancini v. UBS AG: Valuation of Collateral Pursuant to an Event of Default This article discusses the recent case of Mancini v. UBS AG, a case where UBS liquidated Plaintiff’s collateral following an event of default. The issue before the court was whether UBS AG acted arbitrarily when it liquidated Plaintiff’s account based on an earlier valuation date, rather than based on a higher and more recent account value. “Timing is everything” may be a cliché, but when it comes to valuation, it is certainly true. In Mancini v. UBS AG, 2024 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 213279 (S.D. N.Y. November 21,…
-
How Forensic Accountants and Business Valuation Professionals Can Give AI a “Run for its Money” As AI proliferates, business valuation and forensic accountants will need to distinguish between human-authored and AI assisted/generated content. Significantly, AI generated content, as of the date of writing, is not accurate. In this article, the author examines what the above will mean to forensic accountants and business valuation analysts. With the rise of content generated by artificial intelligence (AI), it makes sense that there would also be an increase in online tools that can detect AI-generated content. What does this mean for professionals in the…
-
A Guide to Understanding Social Media Influenced Income for Valuation Professionals While the influencer industry has created numerous opportunities for creators and brands alike, it also presents significant risks. This article aims to explore the challenges faced in this industry and offer insights into how to examine and assess these risks when performing a valuation analysis or assisting with litigation matters involving someone in the influencer industry. The rise of social media has transformed the landscape of marketing and personal branding, leading the way for a new breed of entrepreneurs known as influencers. These individuals leverage their online presence to…
-
Effective Use of AI in Complex Investigations Investigators need better ways to sift through vast quantities of data to find the information at the heart of the matter. This article examines a more efficient approach to complex investigations with Generative AI. The information in this article is intended to assist in determining the effectiveness of using GenAI in fraud and other complex investigations. Introduction Complex investigations are on the rise with investigators being asked to do more with less, therefore needing to gain efficiency to handle workloads. A complex investigation can be triggered by a litigation event, government agency mandate,…
-
What Do I Write About? Writing is an effective way to convey expertise and also a marketing devise. In this article, Rod Burkert shares who he writes for and answers the big unanswered question: how he decides what to write about. I talk about how much I write, who I write for, and when I get it all done. But apparently, I left this big question unanswered: How do I decide what to write about? Deciding What to Write About If you’re thinking of starting a regular BVFLS newsletter or blog, probably the biggest hurdle you’re imagining is: What do…
-
Part II For purposes of valuing an ESOP, the question of what is “adequate consideration” has vexed the author and other BV practitioners. In this article, the author shares an update on the DOL’s response to earlier inquiries. Her two previous articles published in QuickRead detailed the earlier efforts to clarify what constituted “adequate consideration” for the valuation of entities held in ESOPs. On October 25, 2024, the OMB received a proposal on the topic from the DOL intended to clarify how shares in ESOPs are valued via adequate consideration. To date, I have written two QuickRead articles (“Adequate Consideration”…
-
A New Method of Doing Research The introduction of AI tools has empowered companies to streamline complex tasks, enhance accuracy, and offer real-time insights. One such company, IBISWorld, a leader in industry research, has taken a significant step forward with the introduction of its AI tool, “Phil.” This article explores the impact it will have on professionals working in business valuation, forensic accounting, and business consulting fields. As artificial intelligence (AI) continues to transform industries, market research is one of the fields most poised to benefit from these advancements. The introduction of AI tools has empowered companies to streamline complex…
-
The Role of the Expert in 21st Century Dispute Resolution Almost five years ago, the author penned an article published in NACVA’s QuickRead April 14, 2022. In that article, he described what was his perspective as a “recovering judge” of the role of the “expert” in the 21st century profession of dispute resolution. In this article, the author revisits, and in some cases revises, the observations and predictions set forth in the earlier article. Introduction Almost five years ago, I penned an article similarly titled, which was published in NACVA’s QuickRead April 14, 2022. In that article, I described what,…
-
The Role of Life Insurance in Estate Taxes The recent U.S. Supreme Court case, United States v. Connelly, provides business valuation practitioners opportunities to a cautionary tale and also an opportunity to assist business owners structure or restructure their buy-sell agreements. The authors summarize the case and offer tips to assist business owners transition a business using life insurance. Introduction Does the fair market value standard require the insurance proceeds owed to a company at the date of a shareholder’s death need to be added to the value of the business for tax purposes? The Supreme Court ruled that, yes,…
-
Look at the Numbers and Exercise Skepticism Often, business owners will inadvertently present a biased account of their company’s success. Is there a similarity between the bias of business owner’s and crime scene victims? In this article, the author answers this question. Imagine this: you are at the scene of a crime. Witnesses are canvassed, each with their own version of events. One witness is adamant the suspect was wearing a red jacket, another swears it was blue, and a third did not even notice a jacket at all. The accounts are varied, often conflicting, and shaped by personal biases,…
-
You Need Better Clients A frequent question that newly minted and experienced valuation practitioners raise, is how one gets more clients. The question that should be asked is how one gets better clients. The author shares his thoughts on why the latter is the better question and source of focus. Surprise, the most frequent practice development questions I get primarily have this theme: How do I get more clients? What if I told you this is the wrong mindset to have? How would your thinking (and actions) change if we talked about landing better clients instead? Hey, I get it.…
-
Book Review This fall, the American Bar Association released Shannon Pratt’s The Lawyer’s Business Valuation Handbook 3rd Edition. This publication has been edited by Roger J. Grabowski, FASA and Alina Niculita, ASA, ARM-BV, CFA, MBA. It is a comprehensive guide for attorneys (and judges) to enable them to better understand the substance and basis of the valuation expert’s work. In this article, Michael G. Kaplan reviews the book. I Had a Problem! I received a phone call from an attorney. He was representing a client involved in a hotly contested lawsuit involving the impairment of the value of a business.…
-
Marketing Tips for Professional Service Professionals Marc Kohler, an estate planning expert, may offer other professional services professionals a template to follow to secure additional engagement. The article describes how Marc Kohler has marketed his services. In the field of tax law and estate planning (where online engagement can be difficult, if not impossible to obtain), Mark J. Kohler (”Kohler”) has built a following that exceeds 500,000 followers; these followers come from various platforms. This reach is something that many in the professional service industries have only dreamed of. As an attorney and CPA, Kohler has taken what could easily…