In litigation, the issue is whether the expert can explain the analysis, the data, and the judgment that produced the opinion. AI can accelerate parts of that process, but it does not remove the expert’s responsibility for the conclusion. Therefore, the question addressed in this article is where AI can assist without taking ownership away from the expert. A valuation expert can arrive at the stand with years of experience, a detailed model, and a carefully prepared report. However, the expert may stumble when asked to explain an input that came from an AI tool and cannot explain why that…
-
-
Randall v. Widen is a federal court case filed in the Western District of Wisconsin, that involves a redemption. The article focuses on the pre-trial motions involving the admissibility of the experts. In the case, Plaintiff alleged that Defendants failed to disclose material information in connection with the redemption of closely held shares. Arthur C. Clarke once said, “For every expert, there is an equal and opposite expert.” Randall v. Widen, 2025 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 142800, 2025 WL 2081193 (W.D. Wis. July 24, 2025) demonstrates that Mr. Clarke knew what he was talking about. As often happens in litigation Background[1]…
-
A recent 5th Circuit Court ruling reaffirms that earning capacity and lost wages are distinct concepts, and that an economist’s experience-based methodology can satisfy reliability standards even without a post-injury earnings comparison. The author discusses the case. A recent 5th Circuit Court ruling reaffirms that earning capacity and lost wages are distinct concepts, and that an economist’s experience-based methodology can satisfy reliability standards even without a post-injury earnings comparison. Forensic economists who calculate damages in personal-injury matters routinely confront a recurring defense playbook: attack the expert’s assumptions, demand a side-by-side comparison of pre- and post-injury earnings, and argue that anything…
-
Ten Deadliest Mistakes of Expert Witnesses Are you an expert? Technical knowledge isn’t enough, as Michael G. Kaplan explains. An effective expert witness must understand the dynamics of trial, possess excellent communication skills, and have a full command of the litigation process. Here are 10 mistakes that 35 years of experience have taught Kaplan to avoid.