From Vine to Valuation

Understanding Wine Businesses

This article is designed as a primer for valuation professionals, giving you the foundational knowledge of wine industry terms and business structures you need to navigate this highly specialized field. By building this knowledge, you will be better prepared to ask the right questions, interpret key details, and deliver valuations that truly reflect the complexities and risks behind a wine business.

Have you ever stood in the wine aisle staring at a label and thought, “I have no idea what any of this means”? What exactly does Gran Reserva mean? What is a blended wine? Why do some bottles say Old Vine or Non-Vintage? And why do some proudly say Estate Grown while others do not mention it at all? Valuing a wine business can feel the same way, full of unfamiliar terms and hidden details. What is a virtual winery, and how is it different from a vineyard? Why is everyone so worried about something called phylloxera?

As you will discover, the wine industry is a world of its own; part agriculture, part manufacturing, part branding, with a healthy pour of regulatory complexity. It is not just about making good wine, it is about managing land, navigating supply chains, building a brand, federal and state industry administrative rules, and keeping up with evolving consumer tastes. For valuation professionals, this makes the task of valuing a wine business anything but straightforward.

This article is designed as a primer for valuation professionals, giving you the foundational knowledge of wine industry terms and business structures you need to navigate this highly specialized field. By building this knowledge, you will be better prepared to ask the right questions, interpret key details, and deliver valuations that truly reflect the complexities and risks behind a wine business.

First, let’s set the stage with a few foundational concepts in the wine industry. As a valuation professional, it is important to understand these basics as they may come up during management interviews, discussions with owners, and industry reports. We will go over key industry terms and ideas that will be helpful to your understanding of the wine industry.

Phylloxera: A Tiny Pest with a Huge Impact

Let’s start with one of the biggest threats to viticulture. An infamous pest known across the wine world is phylloxera. This is a tiny insect that had a monumental impact on the industry, particularly in the late 1800s when it decimated vineyards across the United States. At the time, most wine-producing vines in the U.S. had been imported from Europe, but it was soon discovered that these European varietals were highly susceptible to phylloxera. Luckily, native American rootstocks were resistant. The solution was to graft these European varietals onto American rootstocks. This practice is known as grafting and has become a staple of modern viticulture. Today, nearly all commercial vineyards rely on this technique to ensure vine health and consistency.

What Does “Estate Winery” Mean?

Another term that you will commonly hear referenced is the designation of an estate winery. This label refers to a winery that produces wine from grapes grown on its own land. For a wine to be labeled as “estate,” at least 85% of the grapes must be grown in vineyards owned or controlled by the winery. Estate wineries are often perceived as producing higher quality wine, largely because they control the process from soil to bottle. This control can command premium pricing and contribute to a stronger brand.

The Role of AVAs in Value

Another designation that has a significant impact on valuation is the American Viticultural Area (AVA). An AVA is a federally recognized grape-growing region defined by specific geographic and climatic characteristics that influence the quality and characteristics of the grapes. With over 270 AVAs across the U.S., they range widely in size, elevation, soil composition, and reputation. Some of the most prestigious and widely recognized AVAs include Napa Valley, Sonoma, and the Willamette Valley in Oregon. Wines produced in esteemed AVAs can fetch higher prices and the AVA designation often enhances the perceived value of both the land and the wine.

Why Varietals Matter

Varietals are another critical factor in wine valuation. A varietal refers to the type of grape used in a particular wine, such as Cabernet Sauvignon, Pinot Noir, or Chardonnay. Different varietals carry different market reputations, consumer demand levels, and pricing strategies. For example, Cabernet Sauvignon from Napa Valley might command a much higher price point than a less popular varietal from a lesser-known region. Understanding which varietals a winery produces and how they align with market trends, the AVA reputation, and winemaker(s) credentials and expertise is crucial in assessing both brand positioning and future sales potential.

Understanding Wine Distribution

It is also important to understand the distribution systems that shape how wine moves from producers to consumers. In the U.S., the three-tier distribution system was established after the repeal of Prohibition through the 21^st Amendment. Under this model, producers must sell to licensed distributors or wholesalers, who then sell to retailers like wine shops, grocery stores, or restaurants. Retailers then sell the product to the end consumer. While this system helps prevent monopolies and ensures tax compliance, it also introduces additional layers of complexity and cost; both of which impact a winery’s bottom line.

As an alternative to the traditional distribution model, many wineries have embraced direct-to-consumer (DTC) channels. These include tasting room sales, wine clubs, and online e-commerce platforms. DTC sales tend to offer higher margins, better control over branding, and stronger customer relationships. As a result, the balance between DTC and traditional distribution can be a key indicator of profitability.

Harvest Season and Vintage Quality

Timing in the wine industry is everything, and harvest season is perhaps the most vital period in a winery’s annual cycle. Harvest typically takes place between August and October in the U.S. and represents the most labor-intensive and high-stakes time of year. The weather, timing, and conditions of the harvest directly influence the quality and quantity of the vintage, which in turn affects pricing, inventory levels, and future revenue. Vintage refers to the year in which the grapes were harvested. Because grapes are highly sensitive to weather conditions, different vintages can produce widely varying results. A particularly good growing season can lead to exceptional wines that command premium prices, while a poor season can result in reduced yields and lower-quality output. I heard through the grapevine that 2023 brought some of the best growing conditions Napa Valley has seen in decades, even rivaling the legendary 2007 vintage. As a result, the 2023 Napa wines are expected to be nothing short of exceptional. Keep an eye out; they may just become collector favorites.

Some wineries also hold back vintages for later release, known as library wines. These are often aged with intention and released during special events or to select wine club members. Library wines typically carry a premium and serve as a strategic tool for both branding and customer engagement.

What is Custom Crush?

Another important aspect of winery operations is the concept of custom crush. In a custom crush arrangement, a licensed winery provides production services to individuals or brands that do not own their own winemaking facilities. These services can include grape processing, fermentation, aging, and bottling. Custom crush facilities are especially popular with startup wine brands and virtual wineries looking to enter the market without the capital investment required to build and maintain their own facilities.

Now that we have covered some of the foundational concepts, it is time to take a step back and look at the broader landscape. The wine industry is made up of distinct but interconnected segments, each representing a different part of the journey from vineyard to glass. From the land where grapes are grown to the label that catches a shopper’s eye on a store shelf, each stage introduces its own business opportunities, cost structures, and valuation considerations.

At its core, the industry centers around four key components: grape growing, wine production, branding, and distribution. A wine business might focus on just one of these areas or span the full value chain. The extent of a company’s involvement across these segments shapes everything from how it generates revenue to where its biggest risks and capital needs lie.

In the sections that follow, we will explore the most common business models you are likely to encounter, breaking down what drives value, what the risks are, and what to look for when assessing value.

Vineyards

When most people think of the wine industry, they likely picture rolling hills perfectly lined with grape vines and harvesters carefully picking grapes; it is the classic image of winemaking. Since the vineyard is where it all begins, let’s start by exploring this classic model of a vineyard-only operation.

The vineyard-only operation is one of the least integrated models as it focuses exclusively on the cultivation and sale of wine grapes to third parties, typically wineries. These businesses do not engage in winemaking, branding, or distribution, making them purely agricultural in nature. While the model is relatively streamlined compared to vertically integrated wine businesses, it presents a unique set of valuation considerations.

Land is the central asset in this model, and its value is heavily influenced by AVA designation, soil composition, climate, and regional reputation. Vineyards in renowned regions like Napa Valley or Sonoma often command higher land and grape prices. Varietal mix is another key driver; premium grapes like Cabernet Sauvignon or Pinot Noir can sell for thousands of dollars per ton, while others may trade for far less. Yield per acre also affects revenue, though in premium markets, lower yields are often intentional to enhance grape quality and pricing.

As an agricultural enterprise, it is not always sunshine and roses. Vineyards are subject to environmental risks, including weather variability, those pesky phylloxera pests, disease, and shifting regulations. Labor shortages, particularly during harvest, can also impact operations. Additionally, vines have a limited productive lifespan, typically 25 to 40 years, requiring ongoing replanting and capital investment. Variability in yield and quality from year to year adds further uncertainty.

As a valuation professional, the key things to consider for a vineyard operation are the quality and location of the land, the selection and diversity of grape varietals, grape yields and pricing, the age of the vines, along with any replanting plans. It is also important to consider the types of contracts the vineyard has in place for selling its grapes. These can include long-term agreements, short-term contracts, or spot market sales. Long-term contracts offer greater revenue stability and can enhance the overall value of the operation, while heavy reliance on spot or short-term sales may signal higher risk. Because a vineyard’s value is primarily derived from its land, it is essential to engage a qualified real estate appraiser with experience in vineyard properties. An accurate real estate appraisal is critical to determining the business value.

Winery-Only (No Vineyard)

While vineyards are the iconic symbol of the wine industry, they only scratch the surface of what this industry truly encompasses. Wineries, another classic term often associated with the wine industry, are frequently confused with vineyards, but they are distinct. A vineyard focuses on the agricultural side, whereas a winery is where the grapes are processed and transformed into wine. Notably, a winery does not need to own or operate its own vineyard to produce wine. The next business model we will examine is the winery-only model. Winery-only operations focus entirely on the production, branding, and sale of wine, without owning or operating vineyard land. These businesses purchase grapes from independent growers, then handle fermentation, aging, blending, bottling, and labeling in their own facilities. As you can imagine, this production-focused business model has very different value drivers, risks, and valuation considerations compared to the agricultural vineyard model.

The ability to source grapes from a range of regions and varietals is a major advantage. Without being tied to a single vineyard, winery-only businesses can tailor their supply to match demand, explore different styles, and adjust to market trends. Brand strength is also central to value. The winery’s identity, reputation, and perceived quality of the wines play a large role in driving pricing and customer loyalty. Another important factor is how efficiently the winery utilizes its production space and labor. It is also essential to consider the winery’s sales channels, whether it sells through wholesale, DTC, or a mix of both, as this directly impacts margins and market reach.

A primary risk in this model is supply chain dependency. Without vineyard ownership, wineries are exposed to fluctuations in grape availability and pricing. Long-term contracts can reduce this risk, but not all winery-only businesses have the scale or bargaining power to secure them, especially in competitive AVAs.

Valuation professionals should examine grape sourcing arrangements, including contract terms, duration, pricing, and supplier diversification. They should also assess the winery’s production capacity and operational efficiency. In addition, reviewing the sales channel mix is important for understanding the margin structure. Finally, it is essential to evaluate the winery’s brand strength, customer retention, and overall market positioning.

Virtual Wineries

The wine industry is rooted in history and tradition, yet it continually evolves with fresh ideas and new players. One of the most notable modern developments is the rise of virtual wineries. These virtual wineries, or simply wine brands, represent an asset-light, innovative twist on a centuries-old industry. These businesses produce and sell wine without owning vineyards, production equipment, or even a physical winery. Instead, they coordinate all aspects of winemaking and distribution through third-party partnerships. The core focus of this model is the brand, marketing, and sales. A key element that makes this business model possible is the custom crush facility, a licensed winery that offers production services like grape processing, fermentation, bottling, and storage. Many virtual wineries also rely on consulting winemakers to ensure quality and consistency, allowing these businesses to focus on branding, marketing, and customer engagement.

Without land or production assets, brand strength becomes the centerpiece of value. Successful virtual wineries carve out a unique brand through storytelling, design, and positioning. A compelling brand can drive premium pricing, customer loyalty, and long-term growth through wine clubs and DTC sales. Customer data, particularly subscription metrics, retention rates, and average order value, offers a clear view of recurring revenue and scalability. Distribution strategy also matters, as a business built around a luxury wine club may have different risks and margins than one targeting broad retail channels.

The virtual model’s flexibility also introduces dependency risk. These businesses often rely on a small number of custom crush partners and grape suppliers, making them vulnerable to price increases, production delays, or quality issues. Since they do not control the supply chain, disruptions at any point can impact output and brand reputation.

Since a virtual winery typically has minimal physical assets, most of its value is rooted in intangible assets such as its brand reputation and customer lists. As such, an income-based approach is often most appropriate when valuing these businesses. When assessing risk, it is important to review the company’s strategic partnerships, including relationships with custom crush facilities, winemakers, and grape suppliers, as reliance on a few key partners can introduce concentration risk. Additionally, understanding the target market segment is critical, since value drivers vary between niche, high-end luxury clientele and broad, high-volume wholesale customers. Other important factors include assessing the strength and recognition of the brand, customer loyalty, wine club performance, and distribution channels utilized.

Estate Winery

Bringing it all together, the estate winery represents one of the most integrated business models in the wine industry. It is a combination of several of the models we discussed above. Estate wineries own and operate every stage of the process from growing grapes and producing wine to branding, bottling, and selling directly to consumers or through wholesale channels. In doing so, they span multiple industries at once: agriculture, manufacturing, marketing, distribution, and often hospitality. This level of control offers strategic advantages, but it also introduces substantial operational complexity and capital intensity.

Owning both the land and production facilities creates unique value drivers and risks that blend the agricultural and production sides of the business. Land remains a core asset, with its value shaped by location, AVA designation, climate, and varietal mix. At the same time, the winery’s brand strength, production capacity, and operational efficiency directly influence revenue potential and profitability. The estate model often commands a premium in the market, as “estate-grown” labels are associated with quality, authenticity, and craftsmanship.

However, the integrated nature of an estate winery can also amplify certain risks. Owning vineyards ties the business to agricultural uncertainties such as weather, pests, and vine health, while the production side carries operational and capital requirements for winemaking facilities, equipment, and labor. Unlike winery-only models that can source grapes flexibly, an estate winery is limited to its own vineyard yields, which can restrict production volumes and create added pressure in poor harvest years.

When valuing an estate winery, it is important to analyze both the vineyard and winery components in tandem. Key considerations include the quality, location, and productive life of the vineyard assets, grape yields and varietals, the efficiency and scale of production facilities, brand strength and reputation, and the mix of sales channels. Understanding customer loyalty and the ability to command premium pricing through the estate designation is equally important.

Like a well-aged Napa Cabernet, the wine industry is layered with nuance and complexity. Valuing a wine business means understanding the land, the grapes, the brand, the people, and the market forces that make each operation unique. Whether you are analyzing a vineyard, a production-focused winery, a virtual wine brand, or a fully integrated estate operation, peeling back these layers is essential to uncover real value and hidden risks. By grounding your analysis in the nuances of industry, you will be better equipped to provide valuations that reflect the true complexity and character of the world of wine.

---

Brianna Solito, CVA, is the Valuation Services Manager at ONE10 Advisors, where she specializes in the valuation of privately held companies in the lower and middle markets across various industries. Her work supports purposes such as gift and estate tax planning, SBA financing, strategic planning, and transactions. Known for her blend of technical precision and thoughtful analysis, Ms. Solito approaches valuation with a craftsman’s mindset, digging deeper, asking better questions, and refining every detail to create work with lasting value. An active contributor to industry thought leadership, she has authored articles, delivered CLE-accredited presentations, and participated in panel discussions to help others make more informed business and financial decisions.

Ms. Solito can be contacted at (863) 513-9861 or by e-mail to bsolito@ONE10Firm.com.