Auto Dealership Business Valuations
Nuances Valuing and Normalizing an Auto Dealership
There are many reasons an auto dealership may require a business valuation; buy-sell agreements, shareholder disputes, employee stock ownership plans (ESOPs), and estate planning and gifting strategies. In many instances, there will be an opposing party that questions the validity of the final value, whether it be a dissenting stockholder or the Internal Revenue Service. It is imperative the dealer be aware of the basic characteristics of a valuation so the dealer is able to make sure the valuation analyst is using sound judgments and that, if challenged, the value will be defensible.
There are many reasons an auto dealership may require a business valuation; buy-sell agreements, shareholder disputes, employee stock ownership plans (ESOPs), and estate planning and gifting strategies.
In many instances, there will be an opposing party that questions the validity of the final value, whether it be a dissenting stockholder or the Internal Revenue Service. ¬†It is imperative the dealer be aware of the basic characteristics of a valuation so the dealer is able to make sure the valuation analyst is using sound judgments and that, if challenged, the value will be defensible.
Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP) were developed by the Appraisal Standards Board (ASB) of the Appraisal Foundation to provide guidelines to be adhered to in performing a valuation.¬† Most professional valuation analysts will conform to these standards.
In addition, the Internal Revenue Service issued Revenue Ruling 59-60 to document relevant factors to be considered when performing a business valuation, which are:
- The history and nature of the
- The economic outlook of the United States and that of the specific industry in
- The book value of the subject company’s stock and the financial condition of the
- The earnings capacity of the
- The dividend paying capacity of the
- Whether or not the firm has goodwill or other intangible
- Sales of the stock and size of the block of stock to be
- The market price of publicly traded stock or corporations engaged in similar industries or lines of business.
Adhering to the above standards and addressing all relevant factors are the first elements that will be scrutinized by someone questioning the valuation. ¬†But what other elements will be examined?
Adjustments may have to be made to historical financial statements to present them in “realistic” terms.¬† For example, abnormal officer compensation or unreasonable rent paid on self-rented property would have to be adjusted to an amount typical in the industry. ¬†These adjustments are called normalization adjustments.¬† Some other normalization adjustments that are common when valuing a dealership might be:
- LIFO Inventory Valuation Adjustments‚ÄĒFavorable tax treatment is afforded dealerships that utilize the LIFO (last-in first-out) method of inventory However, for valuation purposes, the effect of changes in the LIFO reserve does not present a true picture of the dealership’s earning potential.¬† Therefore, a normalization adjustment must be made to reflect income as if the specific identification inventory valuation method was used.
- Uniform Capitalization (Sec. 263A) Adjustments‚ÄĒThe IRS also requires that costs associated with carrying inventory be capitalized (Sec. 263A costs). A portion of expenses such as salaries, employee benefits, rent, telephone, insurance, and data processing must be reclassified and reflected as an additional asset on the balance ¬†If not for the IRS requirement, one hundred percent of these expenses would be reflected and a reduction of economic income would result. ¬†Again, where the books are kept on an income tax basis, normalization adjustment is needed to reverse this entry
- Unusual Commission Structure Adjustments‚ÄĒCommission structures can vary greatly from dealership to Unconventional and uncommon structures may be used as a way of pacifying salespeople or to create additional selling incentives. ¬†Whatever the reason, if the commission expense were not considered within the parameter of the industry norm, a normalization adjustment would be required.
- Non-operating Income and Expenses‚ÄĒWhen a dealership has non-operating items of income and/or expense, they should be removed to reflect a normalized income For example, if a dealership owns real estate from which it is deriving net income that is unrelated to the operation of the business, such net income should not be included on the normalized income statement. ¬†Then the dealership can be valued on an operating basis. ¬†The fair market value of the non-operating assets can be added to the operating value.
- Related Party Rent Adjustments‚ÄĒIn many cases, dealership property is owned by related real estate entities. It is common that rent paid by the dealership is tax-motivated and is not comparable to the going rate of the real estate market. ¬†If this is the case, a normalization adjustment will be made to adjust this expense to the rent charged in the market area.
These are just some of the normalization adjustments that may be required. ¬†Each valuation must be analyzed independently.
It can be expected the adequacy of these types of adjustments will be examined.
One of the most subjective areas of the business valuation is the formation of the capitalization rate. ¬†The dealership’s financial position must be analyzed to identify strengths and weaknesses. ¬†The valuation analyst must assess the risk associated with an investment in the company. ¬†This risk assessment must then be converted into a capitalization rate. ¬†This is another area that could be challenged if scrutinized. ¬†It is important to have detailed backup for all conclusions reached in formulating this rate.
Intangible Value of Goodwill
In every valuation of a dealership, consideration should be given to the intangible value of goodwill.¬† Franchise, agreements, customer contracts, customer lists, and customer relationships all have an intangible worth which must be translated into a goodwill or blue sky value.
The capitalized excess earnings method is the most commonly used method for estimating a company’s goodwill.¬† Utilizing this method will determine what portion of the total value of the company is attributable to goodwill.
An important part of the computation when using this method is the selection of an excess earnings, capitalization rate. ¬†This is the rate used to convert excess earnings into a goodwill value. ¬†Again, this is a very subjective judgment that will be a prime area of scrutiny.
Many dealers have an unrealistic expectation of what the goodwill value of their dealership is. ¬†Public companies such as Penske and Lithia have been paying very high multiples of earnings for dealerships around the country.¬† But is this an indication of the true value of the dealership or a reflection of the premium the public companies are willing to pay to enhance their entire organization for such items as increased overall revenues or the addition of a particular franchise?
The standard of value in a valuation report is usually fair market value which is defined in Revenue Ruling 59-60 as, “the price at which property would change hands between a willing buyer and a willing seller when the former is not under any compulsion to buy and the latter is not under any compulsion to sell, both parties having reasonable knowledge of relevant facts.”
A dealer should want the valuation report to adhere to this concept. ¬†Using high multiples of earnings based on transactions of public companies for most dealerships’ valuations would be inappropriate. ¬†The financial data of the dealerships involved in public company transactions must be comparable to the dealership being valued. ¬†This is usually not the case.
Premiums and Discounts
An important part of any valuation is the selection of appropriate premiums or discounts. ¬†The marketability of the dealership, or the lack thereof, and the interest being valued (either controlling or minority) would have to be determined. ¬†A proficient valuation analyst will use a number of resources including prior court cases to help in determining what premiums or discounts are applicable.
The purpose of a valuation is to value some portion of the stock of the company. ¬†Valuing less than fifty-one percent of the stock is considered a minority interest value. ¬†A purchaser would not be willing to pay the same amount for stock if they are unable to exercise control. ¬†Therefore, a minority interest discount would be appropriate.¬† The reverse of this is true when valuing an interest of more than fifty percent. ¬†This person would be expected to pay a premium for control of the company.¬† Therefore, a control premium would be appropriate.
The stock of a dealership, other than a public company, is not equivalent to stock of, say, IBM. ¬†It cannot be bought and sold on the open market. ¬†Because of this restriction, a discount would be appropriate to account for the lack of marketability.
The application of these premiums and discounts are contingent upon what valuation methods are being used. ¬†The valuation analyst must guard against inappropriate usage.
If an unreasonable or unsubstantiated percentage is used, the entire valuation is in jeopardy of being deemed worthless.
Much of the planning and strategies developed by the dealer to minimize taxes and maximize wealth will revolve around the value of the business. ¬†Once the decision¬† is made to have a business valuation performed, the dealer must make certain that the valuation analyst is going to adhere to the professional standards established and that reasonable judgments will be used so the valuation work ¬†product will stand up to tough scrutiny.
James V. Boland, CPA, CVA, is a Partner with WithumSmith + Brown, P.C., with over 30 years of extensive public accounting experience. Mr. Boland is a partner specializing in the automotive industry. He has performed individual and corporate financial planning, automotive factory financial statement analyses and departmental internal control analyses, product cost studies, and inventory valuations. Mr. Boland also has extensive experience in liquidations and cash flow planning as well as in preparing compilations, reviews, and audits of financial statements.
Mr. Boland can be reached at (732) 572-3900 or by e-mail to Jboland@withum.com.